The title was introduced in 2005, where a 20-man battle royal was held. The last two participants in the match faced off the following week. TGO defeated Saku to become the first-ever ASW American Champion.
TGO is the current champion.
List of Champions:
|1||January 25, 2005||TGO||1||WrestleFestival||1st Champion|
|2||July 25, 2005||Saku||1||SummerFest||Known as "Samoan Championship" while held by Saku.|
|3||January 20, 2005||Titanium Eagle||1||WrestleFestival II||TItle back to being known as American Championship|
|4||November 27, 2005||Grah||1||Season's Beatings|
|5||January 29, 2006||Fernando Hernandez||1||WrestleFestival III||Title known as "Mexican Championship" while held by Fernando Hernandez|
|6||September 24, 2006||TGO||2||Might Makes Right||Title back to being known as American Championship; first 2-time champion|
|7||November 26, 2006||Ubermensch||1||Season's Beatings||Title known as "German Championship" while held by Ubermensch.|
|8||January 28, 2007||Sudden Impact Chris Storm||1||WrestleFestival IV||Title known as "Canadian Championship" while held by Storm|
|9||March 25, 2007||Biff J. Rockenheimen||1||Revenge||Back to being known as "American Championship"|
|10||May 27, 2007||Saku||2||King of Pain||Back to being known as "Samoan Championship"|
|11||September 30, 2007||Biff J. Rockenheimen||2||Might Makes Right||Back to being known as "American Championship"|
|12||January 28, 2008||Saku||3||WrestleFestival V||Back to "Samoan Championship"; First 3-time champion|
|13||January 25, 2009||TGO||3||WrestleFestival 6||Back to being known as "American CHampionship"|